Season 3 Episode 14

Michael Daniel on untangling cybersecurity’s complexity problem

Published:
Updated:
Duration:
35 min

Episode summary

Cybersecurity has a complexity problem. A tangled web of technical, psychological, economic and geopolitical factors enable and motivate malicious actors. Michael Daniel, CEO and president of the Cyber Threat Alliance, is helping public and private organizations decode these complex motivations with information sharing, including the Ransomware Task Force. 

In this episode of WE’RE IN!, Michael elaborates on his “immune system” approach for the internet, a strategy where threats are quickly identified and neutralized. But this requires robust – and highly trusted – information sharing between groups. 

Listen to hear more about:

  • The threat assessment for the 2024 Paris Olympics, highlighting potential threats from Russia and Azerbaijan
  • The need for more resilient software systems that can degrade gracefully rather than catastrophically fail
  • Michael’s thoughts on industry diversification and the value of different viewpoints in tackling cybersecurity challenges

Listen to the episode

S3 E14 · Michael Daniel on untangling cybersecurity’s complexity problem WE'RE IN! Podcast · 35 min

Key takeaways

  1. Plan the communications, not just the defense For events like the Olympics, Michael says organizers should accept that something will go wrong and have an incident response plan that includes telling the public an incident is contained and the games are proceeding.
  2. Software should degrade gracefully The CrowdStrike outage showed that much software is brittle, either fully working or fully crashed, and systems should instead lose functionality gradually to give time to recover.
  3. Do not fully trust trusted channels Because supply chain attacks come through vendor relationships, keep checks inside trusted channels and use risk-based controls you can dial up when threat intelligence shows suppliers are being targeted.
  4. Make cybercrime less profitable Michael's goal is collaboration between law enforcement and the private sector so regular that takedowns of criminal groups stop making the news, changing the economics of cybercrime.
  5. Security is not only a technical problem Phishing is psychology, slow patching is economics, and nation-state activity is geopolitics, so buying another tool will not solve the problem on its own.

Topics covered

  • AI & LLMs
  • Talent Gap
  • Zero Trust

Notable quotes

…if it could be done by accident, it could be done intentionally.

…a lot of software is what I would call brittle, meaning it has two states. It's either working or it's completely crashed.

One thing I remind people is that for all that technology moves fast, people and organizations don't change that rapidly.

We need to continue that diversification because the bad guys do. We shouldn't cede that territory to them.

Questions this episode answers

What is the Cyber Threat Alliance?

It is an information sharing and cyber threat intelligence organization for cybersecurity providers, similar to how the financial sector ISAC serves banks. Members share threat information to better protect their customers. Read this section

Why was Azerbaijan named as a cyber threat to the Paris Olympics?

Michael explains that French support for Armenia was interpreted badly in Azerbaijan, which may seek revenge. He calls it a lesson in how geopolitics plays into cyberspace in unexpected ways. Read this section

What does the CrowdStrike outage mean for cybersecurity?

Michael says that if a flaw like this could be triggered by accident, it could be triggered intentionally. It raises questions about resilience, because much software is brittle and does not degrade gracefully. Read this section

Why do attackers go after the software supply chain?

Compromising one supplier gives access to many targets through a channel those customers trust. The trade-off is that suppliers are usually much harder to breach than a mid-sized business. Read this section

How should ISACs evolve?

Michael wants ISACs connected at a technical, automated level, with governments plugged in, so the internet works like an immune system that shuts down a new threat within a day or two. Read this section

Full transcript

00:01

Intro

Carry nearly 80 gigs of data in my head.

00:03

Intro

You're in the mainframe. It's eating to great entire system.

00:06

Intro

Access encoded. Gigabyte of RAM should do the trick. We're in. In.

00:12

Intro

We're in. In. We're in.

00:15

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Hello, and welcome to WE'RE IN, a podcast that gets inside the brightest minds in cybersecurity. I'm your host, Blake Thompson-Heuer, and I'm thrilled to have Michael Daniel join me on the podcast today. Michael serves as president and CEO of the Cyber Threat Alliance, where he leads the organization's operations and helps to improve the nation's security by enabling near real time cyber threat information sharing among cybersecurity companies. Michael previously served as special assistant to President Obama and cybersecurity coordinator on the White House National Security Council staff. We'll dive into Olympic cyber challenges and go over the CTA's information sharing mission. But first, here's a quick word from our sponsor.

00:54

Sponsor message

Confusion in the marketplace about which is the best method of security testing is so real. Bug bounty, pentesting, pentesting as a service, what do they all mean? We break it down in our latest playbook, navigating the security testing landscape to demonstrate the strategic value of third party security testing. We cherry pick the best elements across the security testing market to incorporate into a strategic, comprehensive pentesting solution, the Synack platform. Learn more at synack.com/playbook. That's synack.com/playbook.

01:36

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Thanks, Michael, for joining me on the program. It's great to have you here.

01:40

Michael Daniel

Oh, thank you for having me. I'm always happy to join.

01:43

Blake Thompson-Heuer

So tell me a little bit about the Cyber Threat Alliance and and your work there.

01:46

Michael Daniel

Sure. So the Cyber Threat Alliance is an information sharing organization, a cyber threat intelligence organization aimed at cybersecurity providers. So you probably have heard of things like the financial sector, ISAC, right, that works in the financial sector to enable banks to share cyber threat information. Well, in many ways, CTA is the same thing only for the cybersecurity industry.

02:11

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Sort of like an information sharing and analysis center, the ISACs that we all know and love. Yes. I was interested to read that the Cyber Threat Alliance got off the ground way back in 2015. Oh, founded before that, but really started picking up steam with this widely read white paper on the CryptoWall crimeware ransomware variant. And here we are nearly a decade later, and and ransomware is still this pretty urgent problem. So how is the Cyber Threat Alliance addressing this ransomware threat?

02:38

Michael Daniel

I mean, first of all, you're absolutely right. I mean, in 2015, ransomware was a problem, but it really exploded a few years later. And I really think that CTA tries to address this problem in a few different ways. One of which is that we enable sharing among our members so that they can better protect their customers and clients. Right? They could get information out about ransomware variants faster. They can share information about mitigation techniques, you know, keys, that sorts of things. We also continue to work on these joint analytic reports like the CryptoWall 3. That... That's what we call them because they're joint reports among all of our members. And because we're based in Washington DC and we like acronyms, we call them JARS. The Of course. Of course. But I would also say that more specifically on ransomware, CTA has been heavily involved with something called the ransomware task force, which has been led out of the Institute for Security and Technology.

03:35

Michael Daniel

I've been one of the co chairs of that ransomware task force since 2021, and we have contributed considerably to the work that IST has done and that that ransomware task force has done on recommendations for how to deal with ransomware, and we try to get that information out as broadly as possible. So ransomware is very much an issue that we're heavily heavily engaged in.

04:01

Blake Thompson-Heuer

That's great. Now, and and speaking of those joint analytic reports, those JARs that you mentioned, the CTA recently issued this... I I don't know if it was technically a JAR, but it was quite a sobering threat assessment for the twenty twenty four Summer Olympics happening in in in Paris. That one was an interesting read. I... It identified Russia, which I guess I'm not surprised to see that country floated as a threat actor, you know, vis a vis the Olympics. But interestingly, Azerbaijan is another relevant threat actor in this space. And and what should France be doing to keep the games locked down and secure from any cyber disruptions?

04:33

Michael Daniel

So, I mean, yes, I, you know, I have to confess that, like, when I was reading the analyst input for that update, I was like, seriously? Azerbaijan? Like, Russia, China, you know? Okay.

04:44

Blake Thompson-Heuer

You don't hear their name come up too often.

04:46

Michael Daniel

Yeah. Right. And and you sort of start peeling back why, and you're like, oh, French support for Armenia has been interpreted badly in Azerbaijan. So, you know, they're trying to take some take some revenge, if you will, push back on that. And it's an interesting lesson about how geopolitics plays into cyberspace sometimes in ways that you don't you don't expect. But I think France has really approached this, I think, in the right way. And they haven't been particularly noisy about it sort of outside of the field, but the level of effort that they've put into doing cybersecurity for the games is pretty extensive. And they're working with a lot of the really top notch companies from around the world. The other thing they're going to have to do is accept the fact that probably something somewhere is going to go wrong in cyberspace. Right?

05:36

Michael Daniel

And so the other thing to have is a good incident response plan, and part of that plan has to be communication. Meaning, how do you get the word out about the fact that this was a cyber incident? We've got it under control. Yes. There was some false information pushed out or this service was disrupted. The games are going on. Everything is proceeding, and we've got this contained. And so I think you really need to be sure that you've actually got that kind of incident response plan, because almost inevitably, something is going to occur during the course of the games.

06:08

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Right. Or even a glitch that people might misinterpret as a cyber attack or something to that nature that you'll need to engage that communication incident response structure anyway. Yeah.

06:17

Michael Daniel

Yeah. Absolutely. Maybe like a software update, you know, just to pick a random...

06:22

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Software update. Just just to throw that out there. No. I actually... Well, it's it's great. It's it sounds like it sounds like Paris and France writ large have really... Similar to how they cleaned up the Seine. I was very impressed. The river, they're... They've cleaned up their cyber act a little bit and are ready for for for a successful Olympics underway now. One question on the Olympics front. How has the threat landscape shifted since Tokyo hosted the games in 2021?

06:45

Michael Daniel

The geopolitical landscape has gotten even more complex, meaning that given the war in Ukraine and the fact that France has been so staunchly supportive of Ukraine means that they are very much the targets for Russia who will want to embarrass them in, you know, any way that they can. I think that, you know, the cybercriminals have continued to evolve. A lot of people throw out AI, although I'm not sure that AI will be as big a driver for, you know, scams and threats to these games, but it's gonna continue to evolve the the criminal landscape in particular. And so I think it's something that everyone should pay attention to in these games to see how it might get used into, you know, malicious cyber activity to get a sense of what it might... How it could even get worse in in future games.

07:37

Michael Daniel

But I think, you know, one of the things that makes the game so complicated from a cybersecurity standpoint is there's just all of the run of the mill cybercriminal activity. Right? Because it's a major sporting event with a lot of people spending a lot of money. So that just attracts the cybercriminals regardless of what is happening in the rest of the world. And then you layer on the fact that it's got a very strong nationalist. You know? Nationalism is built into the games in many ways because the modern games origin is in the late nineteenth, early twentieth century. And so there's that extra layer of geopolitics that makes it even more complicated than just, you know, say a standard standard, you know, major sporting event.

08:22

Blake Thompson-Heuer

That makes a lot of sense. And, obviously, we've seen the Olympics play host to some of the more severe cyber threats in past Olympics of note. Some North Korean activity and Russia linked activity has definitely has definitely made Right. Unfortunate appearances to to sully some past games. It reminds me a little bit of... Had a guest on the podcast not too long ago from the research education networking, ISAC, talking about how complex, you know, securing a a tier one research university really is. You have everybody from... In the Olympics, everybody from the athletes logging in, probably trying to find their schedules or where they're supposed to be. You have guests wanna ensure an experience for the for the spectators and make sure they know where to go and can log in. It's just... It sounds quite quite daunting and especially against the threats that you mentioned. You flicked at this a little bit when you quipped about the software update perhaps throwing things off at the Olympics, but there was some other recent news with CrowdStrike where a faulty update caused quite a disruptive crash of Windows machines around the world.

09:23

Blake Thompson-Heuer

And it's not a cyber threat per se. I know CrowdStrike CEO George Kurtz came out and said this was something that really had to do with an update. But how has the cyber threat alliance been following that development?

09:35

Michael Daniel

I would say sort of in two ways. One is just that, obviously, as part of the response, right, scammers and other cybercriminals have tried to capitalize on the situation to set up a whole bunch of fake CrowdStrike domains and send phishing emails like, hey. Have you been affected by CrowdStrike? Go to this website, which is CrowdStrike spelled with a zero and a three or something that people don't notice. So we've been sharing a lot of information internally about those different malicious domains to try to stay ahead of them, to try to limit their their impact among our members. The other thing that we're discussing is sort of what are the implications for this from a cybersecurity standpoint for this event? And the reason I say that is because while I think CrowdStrike is absolutely right, and I think George Kurtz is completely on target to say this was not, you know, done with malicious intent.

10:33

Michael Daniel

But the issue is that if it could be done by accident, it could be done intentionally. Right? It... Somebody could try to make use of this, what I will call flaw in the Microsoft operating system that allows a piece of code from a third party software to cause this kind of catastrophic event. And I think it really raises questions about what does resilience mean in in cyberspace? And one of the things that I think is actually very true is that a lot of software is what I would call brittle, meaning it has two states. It's either working or it's completely crashed. Like, there's no sort of in between where it has limited functionality or degrades over time. Right? It's either completely working sort of fail gracefully.

11:23

Michael Daniel

Yeah. Yeah. That's right. You know, there's no... There... It's so software ends up being very brittle, and that's probably not a condition that we want to have going forward. So we also need to be thinking about how do you make software and operating systems in these IT systems that we depend on, how do you make them degrade gracefully so that they... You know, the functionality sort of declines, but it doesn't sort of precipitously just crash. And it gives you some time to to recover. And it doesn't mean you wouldn't lose functionality. Like, you would lose some functionality along the way, and it would... That would have impacts, but it would allow you to avoid, for example, the situation where we're, you know, physically having to go around to, I don't know how many, but, you know, millions of laptops, servers, devices, and manually fix them and reboot them.

12:13

Michael Daniel

So I think that's some of the key lessons that we inside CTA have been talking about as a result of the CrowdStrike incident.

12:21

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Less of a blue screen of death and more a a gentle winding blue river to eventually... Eventual failure or something like that. Right. Yeah. I saw some people talking about including it in their black hat presentations, and I'm like, this affected a lot of people. People are still pretty upset. But certainly, you know, highlighted also this concept of, you know, supply chain attacks in quotes. You know, I'm I'm making air quotes because that's become such a a broad term that I I feel like I'm not sure the general public really understands what it means in practice. So what are some of the threat vectors for supply chain attacks, and and what should security teams be thinking about as they tackle a really broad attack surface?

13:02

Michael Daniel

Yeah. So the way that I sort of think about the distinction is that if you're a malicious cyber actor, you've got kind of a choice. So let's say you want to try to get access to information or get access to Acme Corporation. Right? You could try to go after Acme Corporation directly, right, and poke at their web facing, their Internet facing applications. You could try to send some phishing emails to those employees that you know are there. So you could try to go after Acme directly. Or you could say, okay. Well, what do we think that... What kind of software services might Acme be using? Right? Are they using something like a software as a service for all their accounting?

13:54

Michael Daniel

Right? Some sort of thing that... I don't wanna pick on anyone in particular, but it's kinda like the idea of a, you know, QuickBooks or a Zoho. Right? You know? So they're using some, you know, one of those providers.

14:04

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Or a SolarWinds, you know, just to throw that

14:06

Michael Daniel

after that. Pick, yeah, pick another one. But any of those companies that are supplying them software, and so you could, as a malicious actor, oh, if I go gain access to SolarWinds, Zoho, Amazon, pick your supplier. Right? And if I get access in that and then I come through that channel, which that Acme company probably trusts, right, because it's a regular relationship with their vendor, then it'll make it much easier for me to access the... What I want inside Acme. I get the benefit of getting to many targets by going after one as opposed to having to go to each endpoint, each organization separately. And so that's the attraction of the supply chain attacks. Now there's a trade off, right, which is that even for those that have had incidents, right, it is much harder to carry out a successful cyber operation against one of those organizations almost always than it is to carry out one against a mid sized business somewhere, whether in The United States or Brazil or Europe or wherever.

15:10

Michael Daniel

So you've got this trade off that the malicious actors face, which is the payoff's really high, but the work's a whole, you know, a whole lot. And maybe it's riskier, and maybe you get caught and that sort of thing versus a... Maybe a lower payoff, you know, lower return on investment, but an easier time. It's a trade off from the malicious actor standpoint. What I think we have to be aware of and what we have to think about is since we know that these kinds of threats can come through those threat vectors, what you have to start thinking about is that you don't set up these channels where you are sort of like, sure. Everything's okay if as long as it's inside this channel, that you always assume that there could be the possibility of compromise, and so you maintain some of the checks and security even inside those channels that are trusted.

16:00

Michael Daniel

Now I think just like credit card companies and other things have these risk based models for how they assess fraud, like, probably would have risk based models for how you assess that traffic and that channel and other things, and maybe that's another thing that you could dial up or down. Oh, hey. We got threat intelligence that the malicious actors have been targeting these kinds of resellers. Maybe we'll dial up our dial up our protections on any connections we have with those suppliers, and maybe that creates a little bit of friction for our customers. And, you know, we we know that the calls to the complaint center will go up a little bit, but we've accepted that because we know that that's the risk. Right? And then when it changes, we'll dial it back down. And I think that's... You know, we need to start thinking much less than absolutes and more about relative risk in those those kinds of situations.

16:52

Blake Thompson-Heuer

It's such an important concept for even just what we all do in the cybersecurity industry to have that assume breach mentality, navigate appropriately. And then if you do, God forbid, experience something, have those channels to get that information out there and circling back to the work of the Cyber Threat Alliance of of getting, you know, actionable information out to members. I will say it's been a little tricky for me to keep up with all the ISACs that are out there. These information sharing and analysis centers, there are various industries covered. Right? I mean, I mentioned one earlier, the REN-ISAC. You have one for financial services. That was kind of the original that you mentioned. You have, of course, energy, you know, like electricity sector covered. How do you navigate the proliferation of ISACs and ensure that members get the best info that isn't stovepipe?

17:38

Michael Daniel

I think that's a really good question. Right? We've we've seen this sort of explosion of of ISACs, and certainly, some of them are better than others in terms of their capabilities and what's shared. I think the bigger thing in my mind is that if you're... For whatever organization, whether you're a cybersecurity company, whether you're a midsize or large organization that's, you know, doing a lot of your own cybersecurity, the key thing is to make sure that you've got access to the kinds of threat intelligence that you need to do your job, and that you're always assessing where am I getting the best value from that information. And I also think that one of the things that we need to do in this sharing space is we need to, like, there's the National Council of ISACs.

18:28

Michael Daniel

Right? But that's really more about coordination of policy and sort of the... You know, how do the ISACs sort of operate at this very strategic level. We need to also start building the connections between the ISACs at the more of the technical automated level so that we're sharing the information in that community in the background, right, so that we can protect much more of the economy, of our digital ecosystem without actually a whole lot of people ever realizing that it's happening. And I think that's definitely where the industry is gonna have to go. And by the way, government's gonna have to be plugged into this too. And governments. So not just the federal government here in The United States, but state and local governments have to be included, and you have to go internationally. And this is all, like, completely... Say, well, it is almost a completely uncharted territory for how you do this in a way that actually doesn't seem like a giant surveillance net, but that actually provide the kind of threat intelligence that you need In sort of my long term, you know, vision for how I think the industry should operate, it's actually operate a bit like an immune system for the Internet, which means that a threat sort of emerges and, sure, maybe it infects, you know, a few people, a few cells, if you will, in the body.

19:51

Michael Daniel

But then the body starts to react, and it's like, oh, we... We've got... We need to produce some antibodies to this thing. And within, you know, a day or two, it's, like, completely shut down because the defenses are much higher. That totally changes the economic equation for the malicious actors because it means that they can't use the same tools, the same techniques, the same malware over and over and over and over and over and over again for years, and that's really where we have to evolve to.

20:22

Blake Thompson-Heuer

That standardization point that you raised earlier of, you know, getting governments, plural, in various ISACs and organizations. It reminds me of some of the old conversations around the structured threat information expressions, STIX/TAXII frameworks, and getting that threat information out there and and shareable. It's not an easy... On a technical level, that is quite a daunting challenge to get everybody singing to the same tune. So more power to you and the CTA for trying to trying to move the move the ball there. Now what is next for for public private partnerships in cyber? I know that here in The US, the cybersecurity and infrastructure security agencies kinda taken the mantle of that and gained traction as this, you know, newest agency on the block, but the environment is is dynamic, and there are a lot of different agencies involved in the cyber piece. What's your north star for collaboration?

21:09

Michael Daniel

So when I think about collaboration, there's really... I think about three types of collaboration. One is something bad has already happened. Say, a bad software update. Right? But say it's like... More like a NotPetya, right, or a WannaCry. So something goes boom in cyberspace. How do you actually respond, contain, mitigate, recover from that? That's one kind of collaboration. The next kind of collaboration is we can see what might be coming. We can understand the geopolitical environment. We can see what's happening through some of the intelligence in cyberspace, and we can see that hurricane coming. And so how do we do the equivalent of hurricane prep in cyberspace? How do you harden targets? How do you get people ready? How do you inform them? Hey.

21:59

Michael Daniel

This is the weather forecast. Like, you know, some bad stuff's coming your way. That's kind of a second type of collaboration. The third type of collaboration is we know that there are a lot of malicious actors out there, and the only way to impose costs on them is by collaboration between the government and the private sector. So how do you sync up government, particularly law enforcement action, with private sector civil action, you know, cyber defenses and other things to target those malicious actors and do that at a at a... With a regularity that actually means that, in fact, it would be happening... As I say, my goal would be that should happen so frequently that it doesn't even make the news. The takedown of, you know, whatever, the sneaky rat dragon group doesn't even warrant a mention because it happens so often that maybe it's relegated to the police blotter someplace.

22:56

Michael Daniel

Right? That it has the equivalent of, like, somebody getting arrested for, you know, robbery.

23:00

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Kicking over a trash can or...

23:02

Michael Daniel

Yeah. What happened? Yeah. You know, it's like, that's not gonna be front page news because, like, that happens so frequently. Right? And that's where we need to get to. And I would say the first two types of collaboration, we've started to build the structures to do that. This third type of collaboration, we're still struggling with what's the right mix? How do we do that? Who should be involved? Who needs to be at the table? How do you ensure that we don't have private companies doing things that we want governments to do? How do we ensure, you know, prosecutorial integrity? All these things are very complicated. But you can look at the way the ecosystem is designed and say that that's where we have to get to if we want to actually impose costs that anybody cares about that actually make a material difference in how much the bad guys are making. Because at the end of the day... And you'll notice I'm mostly talking about cybercriminals here because I think espionage and sort of nation state activities, that's a different class of thing.

23:57

Michael Daniel

But particularly for the cybercriminals, we've gotta change this economic equation. Because right now, it's a really good business to be in. And Yeah. We've gotta reduce the profit that are available to that business.

24:09

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Yeah. And when you mentioned earlier the contrast, you know, the trade offs in the cybercriminal's mind of do I go after this medium sized business that might be a little poorly defended or go after the supply chain and take home the whole tranche of, you know, everything, there are enough cybercriminals to where the answer is yes to both, I feel like, unfortunately. Right? It's it's been said, kind of related to that point, that the cybersecurity industry has kinda... Is one of these industries that somehow managed to, quote, fail up. Right? And I'm I'm not sure I agree, but just to throw it out there that despite all the smart people working on these problems and, you know, despite all of these solutions and technical acumen out there, you still see, you know, huge front front page news, cyber breaches all the time. What would be your comment on that, and how much have things changed from from your days serving in the Obama administration, for instance?

24:59

Michael Daniel

Actually, know, a friend of mine, Herb Lin out at Stanford one time said, you know, it's really easy to be a cybersecurity expert. Just declare that tomorrow will be worse than today, which was worse than yesterday, and, you know, you'll probably be right.

25:10

Blake Thompson-Heuer

The ever evolving threat landscape. Right?

25:13

Michael Daniel

Right. I think that if you actually look at where we are, when I first started working on cybersecurity in the mid two thousands, there was this... There was questions about, like, does this issue really belong? Is this a national security issue that belongs at the White House level? Is this something that actually belongs in the boardroom? Like, do we really care about this? And, obviously, the answer now is yes. We've clearly made some big strides. The issue is that cybersecurity is very complex, and it actually rolls numerous issues together that we've tried to treat as a single type of technical problem. And the truth is that if you actually look at, like... So just like we were talking earlier, so what's one of the prime ways that an adversary will gain access to a network? Through phishing, which is social engineering. That's psychology.

26:04

Michael Daniel

That's that's human nature in psychology. That's not that's

26:09

Blake Thompson-Heuer

not

26:09

Michael Daniel

what I would call a technical problem. Now there's some technical solutions that you can try to apply to it, but at the end of the day, that's a psychological problem. Why don't businesses patch faster? That's an economic and business problem. Right? Yes. There's some technical issues around that. And if we made it easier to patch, then businesses would probably do more of it. But that's a business economic trade off. Right? The... What drives a lot of the nation states to do what they're doing. It's geopolitics. It's national security. So all of these things mean that you've got this sort of mix of all these different disciplines, all these different industries, all these different business models, all sort of combined into one. And we've tried to just say, alright. The solution to this is some techno, you know, some techno stuff. Just buy the snork flabulator.

26:59

Michael Daniel

Let it flabulate the snorks, and it'll, you know, it'll solve all your problems. Right? And that's just not the reality. And because it is so complex, it's gonna take time as societies to figure out how to how to deal with it. One thing I remind people is that for all that technology moves fast, people and organizations don't change that rapidly. And so even if you look at the adoption curves of previous rounds of technology, yes, they are faster, but they still don't happen instantaneously. The length of time between when Apple issued, you know, the first iPhone, right, really what we sort of think of as this first smartphone, it still took several years for that, you know, to really start to penetrate the market. And even today, we're still sort of expanding, you know, how those devices get used.

27:53

Michael Daniel

I think it's a good reminder that that's why these issues are so complex and why it's so hard to tackle this problem, because it's got all of these different features built into it. And so coming up with the policies and the structures to address the problem is way more complex than just the technology itself.

28:11

Blake Thompson-Heuer

I think people just need to move from snork fabulators to the snork fabulator as a service model, and then they'll be set. Right. But, you know Yes. That's the silver bullet we've been waiting for. No. It's a very good point. A lot of thorny issues. And by the way, to speak to your contributions to these issues and your support for this industry, I saw you were recently nominated for CyberScoop's Cybersecurity Visionary Award alongside the the likes of Jen Easterly and Chris Inglis. So congrats on that.

28:37

Michael Daniel

Oh, thank you.

28:38

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Who do you look up to? Who do you look up to in the cybersecurity space? And who do you credit with really advancing the state of the art in, say, the last ten years?

28:46

Michael Daniel

When I look at it, I look... I do look at people like Chris Inglis, for example. He was really instrumental in driving the setup of the national cyber director and really pushing it to have a strategy that actually said something. I was very impressed with that. And I know that, like, you can... There are all sorts of criticisms that you can lay at the government's feet and and other things. But if you really look at that, that national cyber strategy really has some some definitive direction in it and says, this is where we're gonna go from a strategic level. That's very impressive. But there are other people that, you know, I worked with in government who aren't household names, who actually don't even like their names being out there, that I learned a lot from about how to think about cybersecurity, right, and how to think about it as a complex systems issue as opposed to just a, you know, technology problem.

29:39

Michael Daniel

And so I I really try to learn from everybody across the board. I've also started really trying to look at what people coming out of universities and graduate schools and, you know, other places, they're starting to bring to the table as well some different perspectives, and I think that's always very useful. And it actually gets me to a point about... That I think is really important for the industry, which is we have got to continue our efforts to diversify the industry and bring in different different perspectives. And, you know, what kind of perspectives? All of them. Because, again, if this is an economic problem, if it's a psychology problem, if it's a legal problem, if it's a cultural problem, then you need people from all different, you know, all different perspectives, different countries, different, you know, socioeconomic strata, different cultures and ethnic groups, like, you name it across the board.

30:33

Michael Daniel

We need to continue that diversification because the bad guys do. We shouldn't cede that territory to them.

30:39

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Now that's a really good answer and a really good point as well on not only the need to build a bigger tent in the cybersecurity industry, but also the fact that, you know, not everybody who's made really significant meaningful contributions to the field is gonna be the type to wanna jump on a podcast. We we have a very neuro diverse industry. We have a very... People who have really intense clearances, who are working behind the scenes, don't even wanna dare come out of the woodwork to say anything. And that's that's a really good point. The the unsung heroes of cyber a little bit. So thanks for for reminding us of of those folks.

31:09

Michael Daniel

Oh, yeah. I mean, there were definitely... There were people that I worked with at the White House who, you know, I would look at them and I would say, boy, am I glad you're on our side because that's really wicked evil, to what we could do. And so, you know, I was very glad that their creativity and things was for the force of good as opposed to something else.

31:31

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Yeah. That's a that's a good point. And I'd love to love to love to hear more about those days, but obviously, when the time is right with a memoir, maybe. Yep. So finally, this is something that we ask all of our guests of the podcast, which is what's something that we wouldn't know about you, Michael Daniel, just by looking at your LinkedIn profile?

31:49

Michael Daniel

Well, so one of my favorite pastimes that might appear to, you know, sort of one line down at the bottom is I studied Japanese martial arts, and I have for close to thirty years now. And it is a... It's really a big aspect of my sort of personal life. We're getting ready for an exhibition trip next spring to to Japan to go to Kyoto and do some demonstrations with martial arts experts from around the world. And it's something that I'm very... I I I think really helps provide a lot of balance and a lot of discipline into my life, and I have a lot of friends through the martial arts. And so it's really just a big part of of who I am these days.

32:34

Blake Thompson-Heuer

That's... I did not know that about you, and that is very impressive that you'll be traveling and practicing some of those skills and getting that fulfillment from that activity. That's... That sounds like a really interesting one. I'd love to learn more about Japanese martial arts. I'll admit I'm not I'm not the most well versed in those in those arts myself.

32:49

Michael Daniel

Well, it's a great... You know, it's... They're very old. They've been studied for thousands of years, but yet, you know, there are practitioners from all over the world. And the last time we were in Japan, I thought that one of the things that really struck me was that in the sort of adult category, our youngest participant was 15, and our oldest participant was 93. I definitely wanna be that guy. I wanna be 93 years old and still able to demonstrate on the dojo floor, which is, you know, extremely, extremely impressive. And so I just think that the way that that brings different cultures and different people have come to study these these arts and look at it through the Japanese lens and... But yet bring their own, you know, culture to it is really makes for a very dynamic and interesting environment to be in, and it's one that I really like.

33:38

Blake Thompson-Heuer

Well, that... That's awesome. And and thanks so much again for for joining me on the podcast. Really great discussion.

33:42

Michael Daniel

Oh, thank you for having me.

33:44

Blake Thompson-Heuer

If you liked what you heard today, I hope you'll give us a five star rating and review. It's a big help. And please share this episode if you know anyone who could appreciate a little info sec wisdom on their morning commute. We have a whole catalog of episodes well worth a listen, so you may wanna check out past interviews as well. Finally, if you know someone who might be a good fit to appear on the podcast podcast or have any comments or feedback, drop us a line at we'[email protected]. That's s y n a c k dot com. Until next time.

34:16

Sponsor message

We're in is brought to you by Synack. If you're looking for on demand continuous access to the world's most skilled and trusted security researchers, you can learn more at synack.com. Synack recently launched its Empower Partner Program so that partner organizations can more easily offer the Synack platform to their own customers. This approach helps optimize Synack partners technical competencies and allows them to better integrate Synack into their portfolios. It's a way that partners can win new business by adding continuous best in class solutions to cybersecurity, cloud, and DevSecOps offerings. Synack partners with organizations around the world to make them safer, more resistant to cyber attacks, and more capable of finding and fixing dangerous vulnerabilities before attackers are able to exploit them. Learn more at synack.com. That's synack.com.

Enjoyed this episode? Browse all WE'RE IN! episodes →